My photo
Hong Kong, Dubai, London, San Franciso, Sydney, Singapore
W: www.redflaggroup.com / E: contact@redflaggroup.com

Wednesday, 3 February 2010

US businesses failing to make ethics disclosures

Companies are dodging ethics disclosures that were put in place to deal with the types of misconduct that brought about the downfall of energy giant Enron in 2001, according to the authors of a new study.

Conducted by University of Georgia law professor Usha Rodrigues and Texas Tech University professor Mike Stegemoller, the study examined the disclosure of related party transactions that are required under section 406 of the US Sarbanes-Oxley act, which requires public companies to disclose the code of ethics, or explain the lack of one. It also requires companies to reveal immediately whenever it grants a waiver of that code to its top three corporate officers.

The results of the study, which will be published in the March edition of Virginia Law Review, found that companies are either delaying such disclosures, or have failed to do so altogether, according to a report published in Compliance Week. What is more, the authors also found no evidence that the US Securities and Exchange Commission has ever sought to enforce non-compliance of the rule.

“Companies aren’t disclosing the information the way they’re supposed to. They are not labelling it correctly and they are delaying the disclosure,” Ms Rodrigues told the trade publication.

In conducting the study, the authors examined US corporate filings between 2003 and 2008. They found that during the entire period, there were only 36 instances where waivers for section 406 were filed with the SEC. The report noted that section 406 was drafted in reaction to the Enron accounting scandal of 2001, in which special purpose entities were used by senior corporate officers to keep debts off the energy giant’s balance sheet and off the public radar.

To mask their failure to make the required ethics waiver disclosures, the authors said one tactic adopted by companies is to make the disclosure for related party transactions in the annual proxy statement, which are filed separately, instead.

In other cases, companies have watered down their ethics codes so that they did not disallow the types of violations that led to section 406’s adoption. This meant they were able to minimise the need for disclosure.

The authors said they believe that one reason why companies have chosen to shy away from making the required disclosures is because they were unfamiliar in dealing with corporate codes of ethics, which have only been recently introduced to many organisations. They believe companies did not yet have a system in place to flag violations or waivers as they happen. Alternatively, they said other companies may have intentionally chosen to ignore the disclosure requirements because the SEC is unlikely to enforce it, the report said.

To address concerns, the authors suggest that the ethics waiver disclosure requirements be eliminated altogether. Instead, all public companies should require its CEO, CFO, or chief accounting officer to disclose related party transactions immediately, rather than in the annual 8-K filing, they argued.

Companies with compliance programmes to get lighter sentences

Companies in the US which have implemented compliance programmes could see their penalties reduced if found guilty of white collar crime under a proposal being floated by the US Sentencing Commission.

The independent federal agency, which is charged with issuing guidelines to assist US judges during sentencing, has suggested that judges should take into consideration during sentencing whether companies have in place corporate compliance programmes designed to fight corruption, according to a report which appeared in the Wall Street Journal.

However, the proposal, which is being released by the commission as part of a public consultation exercise, will require that a company’s compliance officer to have direct access to its board of directors in order to qualify for the lenient treatment, the report said. The compliance officer must also be made responsible for detecting criminal activity in the organisation, and misconduct must be reported in a timely manner to the authorities.

If a company meets these requirements, it could qualify for lenient treatment even if its senior officers were involved in the misconduct, the report said.
William Sessions III, the agency’s chairman, said the idea behind the proposal is to foster direct communication between compliance officers and the corporate board of directors in companies, elevating the tackling of corruption and wrongdoing to the most senior levels of organisations.

He said it was designed to help companies obey the law, even if some of its corporate officers had not. “You are basically circumventing the people responsible for the illegal act,” he told the newspaper.

The proposal will now be discussed in a public hearing on March 18, with the commission expected to vote on it in April.

Tuesday, 26 January 2010

Chinese Corruption Crackdown Spreads; Companies with Business Relationships with Chinese Government Officials Need to be Increasingly Vigilant

[Press Release] HONG KONG, Jan. 24 /PRNewswire/ -- With the news that Chinese graft-busters have targeted officials in the Guangdong city of Maoming in their on-going anti-corruption drive, foreign businesses operating in China need to reassess their dealings with government officials to identify whether they have been involved in activities that could be perceived as bribery and put a stop to it, says The Red Flag Group.

In recent years, Chinese efforts to crackdown on corruption among government officials have mainly focused on the so-called first-tiered cities. This included the sentencing in 2008 of Chen Liangyu, Shanghai's former communist party chief, and the dismissal of XuZhongheng, a former major of Shenzhen, both for bribery.

However, in a sign that the crackdown is turning towards emerging tier two cities, Chinese language media have reported that officials in the city of Maoming are being investigated for corruption. They include Yang Guangliang, Maoming's vice-mayor, who was placed under detention by the Central Commission for Discipline Inspection last October. Also targeted was Cheng Bin, the police chief of Maoming Public Security Bureau, and Yang Qiang, director of Maoming's Maogang district police bureau.

This followed other tier two city officials who have been recently netted by Chinese graft-busters, such as Chen Xizhao, deputy chief of police in the Guangdong city of Lianjiang, who was fired after it was reported that he invited 1,000 guests to a Christmas party at his residence. Also, Ye Shuyang, a former police chief in the city of Shaoguan, was arrested in 2008 and is set to stand trial for accepting more than 30 million yuan in bribes over a period of 20 years.

"Whereas previously, China's anti-corruption drive have mainly been focused in the largest cities such as Guangzhou and Shenzhen, what we are seeing now is the effort moving towards normally less high profile places such as Maoming," said Scott Lane, Principal and CEO of The Red Flag Group.

"What this means is that now more than ever, companies not only need to proactively assess business they have done with Chinese officials in the past, but also with any officials with whom they have established any sort of relationship, regardless of whether money has ever changed hands," Lane said, adding that it was important to identify activities that may have supported bribery. Companies need to analyze the different transactions that have taken place, whether they are deals, the use of third parties, or giving gifts or lavish entertainment to officials.

"In a country where the provision of gifts and lavish meals is a routine part of the business dealings, companies more than ever need to make sure they can keep track of and maintain thorough records of all gifts, entertainment and travel it provides to business relationships. It is only then that managers can have the information they need to spot red flags early, and prevent activity from occurring that incurs the full wrath of Chinese fraud investigators," Lane added.

"A company's compliance personnel should be able to use software, such as our ComplianceDesktop Gift and Benefits Tool, to make queries. They should be able to type in the names of the officials, and see whether any gifts or entertainment had been provided to the said officials, along with details such as what they were, the cost, when it was given, and whether there were any special circumstances," he said.

Requiring installation of no new hardware or software, the tool, which is part of ComplianceDesktop's anti-corruption suite, adapts and automates a company's gifts and entertainment policy by allowing for automatic approval of certain expenses which meet pre-set criteria. If a situation arises in which employees need guidance on whether they can give a certain gift to a certain official, they can access the tool using a web-based interface or a web-enabled mobile phone. By answering a number of questions, the tool can calculate whether the gift can be given according to the company's policies, as well as any further rules or additional procedures that must be followed.

In addition, the tool also allows employees to provide detailed records whenever they are giving gifts, including details of the recipient such as their name, affiliation, and contact information. It also allows for the generation of customized reports to suit each individual company's needs.

"ComplianceDesktop's Gift and Benefits Tool is an inexpensive and powerful way to allow companies to keep track of all out-going gifts. This is especially so considering the enormous lost opportunity and real cost that companies can experience if they get caught by Chinese graft-buster for giving an official an appropriate gift, even if it was given with the most innocent of intentions," Lane said.



About The Red Flag Group

The Red Flag Group is one of the world's leading independent Corporate Governance and Compliance firms providing thought leadership around Compliance to Fortune 1000 companies. Our main goals include helping companies develop and maintain efficient and effective Governance and Compliance programs in the emerging markets. The firm consists of ex in-house counsel and compliance officers and have offices in the USA, Hong Kong, Sydney, Singapore, London, and Dubai. For more information, go to www.redflaggroup.com.

SOURCE The Red Flag Group

Sunday, 24 January 2010

Ex-Credit Suisse broker jailed for 5 years

A former broker at investment Credit Suisse has been jailed for five years for misleading his clients by telling them that nearly US$1 billion was being invested in US government backed student loans, when in fact were tied to more risky sub-prime mortgages.

Eric Butler, formerly a managing director in Credit Suisse’s private banking division in charge of the corporate cash management group, was also ordered to pay a US$5 million fine. The recent sentce follows his trial and conviction last August. Federal prosecutors had originally asked for a sentence of at least 15 years.

According to facts unveiled during last year’s trial, between 2005 and 2007, Mr Butler, whose unit was responsible for helping clients manage excess corporate cash holdings, and a colleague misled clients by either sending or directing assistants to send emails with names of securities falsified to make them appear less risky.

This was done by removing terms referring to mortgages or collateralised debt obligations (CDO), which is type of product tied to sub-prime mortgages. Prosecutors said this was replaced with words which created an impression that the investments, consisted of auction rate securities totalling around US$900 million, were backed by student loans, and the clients were told that the product was a safe alternative to bank deposits or money market funds.

As a result of this scheme, some of Butler’s clients, which included sophisticated corporate investors the likes of drug company GlaxoSmithKline, lost as much as US$500 million, when the market for auction rate securities tied to CDOs froze in 2007.

Butler’s clients were then left with securities whose values sank as mortgage defaults rose. On the other hand, the sale of the products generated high commissions for Butler and his colleague.

A spokesman for Credit Suisse, David Walker, told the Wall Street Journal: “Since 2007, when we promptly informed our regulators of this matter, Credit Suisse has assisted the authorities to bring these individuals to justice.”

Paul Weinstein, Butler’s lawyer, said his client would seek to appeal the sentence.

DoJ nets largest number of individuals in record FCPA case

In what is to date the largest number of individuals netted in a single FCPA case, the US Department of Justice (DoJ) has arrested and charged 22 executives at military and law enforcement production companies with attempting to bribe foreign government officials to win business contracts.

The 22 executives, who hailed from different companies based in the US, UK, and Israel, were indicted at the conclusion of a joint undercover sting operation carried out in cooperation with the FBI. It marks the first time that the DoJ has made use of such a technique in going after US companies who bribe foreign officials, as well as being the largest single investigation and prosecution against individuals in the history of the department’s enforcement of the US Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA).

“This on-going investigation is the first large scale use of under-cover law enforcement techniques to uncover FCPA violations and the largest action ever undertaken by the DoJ against individuals for FCPA violations. The fight to erase foreign bribery from the corporate play book will not be won overnight, but these actions are a turning point. From now on, would be FCPA violators should stop and ponder whether the person they are trying to bribe might really be a federal agent,” said Lanny Breuer, assistant attorney general of the DoJ’s criminal division.

According to the indictments, the accused allegedly engaged in schemes to pay bribes to the defence minister of an African nation. As part of the undercover operation, FBI agents posed as sales agents who were led to believe represented a minister of defence in a country in Africa. The executives are accused of allegedly agreeing to pay a 20 per cent commission to the sales agent, in what they believed would lead to the award of US$15 million contract to outfit the country’s presidential guard.

The accused executives, who are aged between 25 and 66 and hailed from a range of companies producing gear ranging from small arms, to ballistic vests and armoured vehicles, were told that half of this commission amount would be paid directly to the said defence minister. They also agreed to prepare price quotations in connection with the deal, one which represented the true cost of the contract, and another which included the extra 20 per cent kickback. The executives also allegedly agreed to do a small test deal to show the fictitious defence minister that he would receive the 10 per cent bribe.

They were arrested in Las Vegas and in Miami by FBI agents, and all were charged with conspiring to violate the FCPA, conspiring to engage in money laundering, and engaging in substantive violations of the FCPA. The indictments also sought to forfeit any illegal profits the company may have generate from bribery. If found guilty, the executives each face a maximum prison sentence of five years for both the conspiracy and FCPA counts, as well as 20 years for money laundering.

Sunday, 17 January 2010

Johnson & Johnson accused of paying kickbacks to raise drug sales

Drug company Johnson & Johnson has been accused of paying tens of millions of dollars in kickbacks to a US nursing home pharmacy company to increase sales of drugs to patients.

The US Department of Justice (DoJ) said between 1999 and 2004, the pharmaceutical giant illegally paid Kentucky-based Omnicare, the biggest pharmacy serving nursing homes in the US, to buy Johnson & Johnson drugs and to promote their use at nursing homes. The kickback were directed towards a number of the company’s products, including Propulsid, Levaquin, Procrit, Duragesic, and Ultram, but the biggest share of the payments revolved around Risperdal, which is prescribed to help control anxiety.

According to the report which appeared in the Wall Street Journal, it is common in the pharmaceutical industry for drug makers to pay rebates for drugs sold through middlemen, such as Omnicare, whose role it is to process prescriptions, distribute the drugs, and manage insurance coverage. The practice is not illegal. Instead, prosecutors are accusing Johnson & Johnson of hiding the rebates, partly by disguising them as payment for information that Omnicare usually provides for free to drug company clients.

The report said that intermediary companies such as Omnicare often wield strong influence in the drug making business, because they determine the brands of drugs prescribed to millions of patients in the US.

The 34-page complaint cites evidence such as admission in internal presentations by Johnson & Johnson executives of the pivotal role played by Omnicare in product selection by nursing home patients. In one email, the company calculated that US$3 million in rebates would result in US$9 million in sales, with a net return of US$4.8 million. In 2000, the two companies entered into a four-year agreement, involving a payment of US$4.65 million to Omnicare, in return for the pharmacy company making an effort to persuade patients to switch to Johnson & Johnson products.

The complaint also alleges that Johnson & Johnson sponsored Omnicare’s annual national managers meeting at a Florida resort. Between 1999 and 2004, the drug company paid US$50,000 for the sponsorship each year, and in return its sales managers were able to rub shoulders with Omnicare managers, and persuade them to buy more of the company’s drugs. The report goes on to say that the DoJ complaint was brought about by two whistle-blowers who were former employees at Omnicare.

Johnson & Johnson, which is based in New Jersey, has responded by saying that its acts were “lawful and appropriate”, and that the company is looking forward to defending against the claims in court. The company did not elaborate further.

SEC names unit heads, new enforcement measures

The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has named the heads of the five specialist investigation units and its market investigation unit – which were created last year, as it continued what it described as its biggest shake-up since its establishment in 1972.

Concurrently, SEC Enforcement Division director Robert Khuzami also announced new measures and tools designed to help the beleaguered agency, which has been criticised for missing massive fraud such as that perpetrated by Wall Street swindler Bernard Madoff, ferret out white collar crime earlier.

The appointments announced by the SEC include Thomas Sporkin, former deputy chief at the SEC’s Office of Internet Enforcement, who will take over the new Office of Market Intelligence. Bruce Karpati, founder and head of the commission’s Hedge Fund Working Group, and Robert Kaplan, previously an SEC enforcement division assistant director, will take charge of a unit focused on asset management.

A unit looking into large scale market abuses and manipulation will be led by Daniel Hawke, who was director of SEC’s Philadelphia office. Structured and new products will be overseen by Kenneth Lench, also formerly an assistant director at the SEC’s enforcement division. Cheryl Scarboro, previously an associate director in the SEC’s enforcement division, will head the unit focusing on violations of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, while Elaine Greenberg, former the associate regional director of the SEC’s Philadelphia regional office, will take up leadership of the unit scrutinising municipal securities and public pensions.

“These specialised units address both challenges through improved understanding of complex products and markets, earlier and better capability to detect emerging fraud and misconduct, greater capacity to file cases with strike-force speed and an increased in expertise throughout the division. By making connections between similar tips from different outside sources, our new Office of Market Intelligence will enable the division to better focus resources on those tips and referrals with the greatest potential for uncovering wrongdoing,” Mr Khuzami said.

Mr Khuzami also announced the agency will now authorise staff to use tools, inspired by those used by the Department of Justice and which were previously unavailable to them, in eliciting cooperation from companies and individuals during investigations.
They include cooperation agreements, which recommend the bestowal of credit for cooperation in investigations where substantial assistance has been rendered, and deferred prosecution agreements, where the agency agrees to forego for a limited period, any enforcement act provided the other party agrees to cooperate fully in an investigation and to comply with conditions either prohibiting or requiring certain actions.

Finally, SEC enforcement staff will be allowed to use non-prosecution agreements, in which the commission would agree to not prosecute an offender provided that they provide cooperation.

Mr Khuzami also said the SEC has also streamlined the process for submitting witness immunity requests to the Justice Department, as well as set out clearer guidelines on how it evaluates the cooperation provided by companies and individuals during enforcement investigations.